Case Study 3

For this assignment we were to review the same news story from 3 different international sources. I chose to cover the release of secret emails detailing Osama Bin Laden's burial at sea.

My sources were as follows:

1. Aljazeera - Secret details of Bin Laden burial revealed

2. New York Daily News - Internal emails offer details on Osama Bin Laden's Burial

3. Daily Mail - Revealed: Military emails show that NO U.S. sailors witnessed Osama Bin Laden's secret burial at sea

The Associated Press were able to successfully invoke the Freedom of Information Act to obtain e-mails about the burial of Osama Bin Laden. These e-mails detailed the delivery of Bin Laden's body as well as the process of the burial such as the fact that they followed Islamic burial practices in preparing his body.

One thing that all three articles pointed out was the fact that while the Obama administration has made the promise to be transparent and open with the public, this is has been one of the most secretive operations in recent history. No photographs or video have been released and even the burial was done secretly. The articles all point out that while it was done on a Navy ship, no naval/military personal that were not high ranking were in attendance or knew about it. The Daily News article even pointed out that the Pentagon has said they have no records of DNA results, a death certificate, or autopsy report.

The differences are few and far between. Stylistically they were all very similar and I felt they seemed fairly balanced and free of much political or social bias, but I did notice that the article from the NY Daily News focused a bit more on the actual capture and killing of Bin Laden, even going so far as ending the article with a fairly graphic quip about his death - "Their target ducked into his bedroom, where SEALs chased and plugged him with one shot to the chest and one to the head." It seems like a fairly strange way to end the article but maybe because it is American, and specifically it is from New York, they know that their demographic likely has a much more personal connection with the story.

As far as where the stories were located, it was fairly easy to find them. For Al Jazeera I simply clicked on the "Americas" link and it was one of the top stories. For NY Daily News, it was listed under News and World. For Daily Mail it was under News and Headlines. So all were fairly visible, but on Al Jazeera it was the easiest to find.

Ultimately I found myself surprised by how similar each of the articles were. I imagine this is due to the fact that the information was (from what I gathered) originally released by the Associated Press and so these journalists were all working from the same source material. I found the Daily Mail article to be slightly more interesting due to the extra photos and a few extra facts given and the Daily News article to the be the least due to the unnecessary inclusion of graphic details about Bin Laden's death, but ultimately they were all pretty similar and reflected the same information.